Geiger Key - , Florida

Introduction to Geiger Key

Geiger Key, located at Address: Florida 33040, USA, is a hidden gem known for its enchanting island experience. While specific contact details such as phone number and website aren't widely published, the essence of Geiger Key shines through the glowing reviews it has garnered, particularly on Google My Business. With 40 reviews boasting an impressive average opinion of 4.6/5, it's clear that Geiger Key is a destination that does not disappoint.

Location & Contact Information

Specialties and Highlights

Geiger Key is renowned for its island specialties, offering visitors a unique dining experience that celebrates the local seafood. The menu features mouthwatering dishes like Grouper fingers, prepared to perfection, which is a testament to the quality of ingredients and culinary skill on the island.

Dining Experience

• Fresh, beautifully cooked fish dishes that are a must-try.
• A key lime pie that's celebrated as one of the best in town, offering a sweet end to any meal.
• An overall dining atmosphere that is described as private, quiet, and safe, providing a perfect escape from the hustle and bustle of daily life.

Why Visit Geiger Key

For those seeking a tranquil getaway, Geiger Key offers an idyllic setting. The reviews highlight the peaceful environment and the spectacular view, making it a paradise for nature lovers and those in search of a serene retreat. The service is noted to be impeccable, ensuring a pleasant and memorable visit.

Other Points of Interest

• The drive up to Geiger Key is recommended as an adventure in itself, adding to the overall excitement of the visit.
• The private and beautiful location provides the perfect backdrop for relaxation and enjoying the island's natural beauty.

Insights from Reviews

Potential visitors are encouraged to take note of the consistent praise for the food quality, with particular mentions of the fresh fish and the key lime pie. The service has been universally praised, indicating that guests can expect a high standard of hospitality. Reviews also suggest that the island's privacy and safety contribute significantly to the overall positive experience, making it a safe haven for a stress-free vacation.

👍 Reviews of Geiger Key

Jennifer S.

5/5

Been coming to KW for so many years and a couple times heard about Geiger Key but we haven’t stopped, this trip we finally did and it did not disappoint!! Highly recommend the drive up to it!! We had the Grouper fingers and they were cooked perfectly!!

Heather B. B.

5/5

I love it here...very private , quite, safe and a beautiful view....paradise.....peaceful

Justine A.

5/5

Fantastic food, the fresh fish was amazing and the absolute best key lime pie ever. The view was spectacular and the service was perfect. I can’t recommend this place enough.

Midwest R. C.

5/5

We just returned from a week at Geiger Key! What a great place to stay. Quiet but yet close to Key West. The Marina is friendly and accommodating! The food is excellent as well as outstanding attentive service!!

Bleu R.

5/5

Great fresh food... Nice portion sizes... Great atmosphere... "The Best Known Secret"
Justin is a great server, he was very knowledgeable of the menu and very nice. We really enjoyed our visit and recommend everyone to enjoy the same experience.

Kirstin A.

1/5

We went here in Spring 2017 we booked through Expedia at last minute for 5 days. We got there and we're impressed we had a brand new 5th wheel camper on waters edge. But our 5 days was cut short to 2 nights as we were told Expedia double booked us. After hours on the phone with Expedia and them crediting us 3 days at the Marriot in Key West we went home wanting to come back and spend our entire next vacation in the new camper on waters edge. Fast forward a year and I made reservations for this April back in December. I called Geiger Key directly as hoping to avoid any problems with a 3rd party booking. I made our reservation for 10 days and specifically requested the camper on the water that we stayed in last year. We planned our vacation around when that one was available for 10 days. We arrived at the marina to be given a camper that was about 15 years old, half the size and no where near the water. We were told the one we requested had mildew smell and had a party of 7 checking in the following day. That was their only camper that accommodated that many people. They tried to blame Expedia again but I informed them I booked direct through the woman that was telling me it was Expedia fault. I demanded our money back which they did however we stayed the one night due to our non refundable deposit and to allow time to find different place to stay in the keys at the last min again. We will never return these people are rude and almost ruined our vacation not once but twice and then they blame Expedia. They use the only nice camper for min stay for all first time guests so you get hooked and then use the old bait and switch technique. On top of that they are rude. Don't stay here unless you have your own camper but even then there are much more beautiful RV sites to stay numerous places along Overseas Highway from Islamorada to Key West that are on open water and the people are amazing. I will also be contacting Expedia so they don't continue to fix problems they are not responsible for in hopes they don't allow this company to book through them.

ROCK T. B.

5/5

Stopped over to Geiger key to grab a bite to eat at the Geiger Key Fish market. Geiger Key is close to us and only about 5 miles east of Key West. It is located to the south of, and bridged to, Big Coppitt Key via Boca Chica Road at about mile marker 11 on U.S. 1. It has the small trailer park community of Tamarac, Geiger Key Pub & Grill and Geiger Key Marina

timothy P.

4/5

Great getaway spot... prepare yourself for possible old saggy balls though