Fireside Dinner Theatre - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

Diane R.

This is a top- notch dinner theater. The atmosphere is so chill and relaxing. The food and service is outstanding!! I haven't been to a show there in years but people flock there for quality stage productions!!! They do host our film premieres there which I love. I highly recommend this place!!

Sim

The Fireside was amazing! We came on a Friday and the Cod was phenomenal, and then we saw the 3 Heath Brothers and absolutely loved them!
This place is a gem! The atmosphere is great and the staff is above and beyond friendly!

Jennifer M.

Always a great time at The Fireside! This was our first time going for a brunch show. The food was phenomenal as it always is! Everything brunch/breakfast you could think of was on the buffet along with a few "dinner like" options such as teriyaki salmon, ham, turkey, egg noodles and beef. They started us off with little breakfast pastries vs their normal homemade bread offerings along with mini strawberry basil smoothies which were superb! The show was excellent!! Just what we needed to kick off the Christmas 2024 season, miracle on 34th st! Loved it! The shops are always filled with fun holiday items!

Kirsten P.

Great Show, Horrible Food

I drove seven hours from Cleveland to watch my cousin perform. Had never been to a dinner theater before. The show was great, it was nice how close the stage was. I would rate the food negative if I could. For being a dinner theater I expected an exquisite experience. The soup was from a can at best, the main dish (I had Halibut) was so overcooked and lacked flavor and the veggies were inedible. Everyone else except one (who also had the halibut) had the pork and they said it was not good either. Fast forward to 2am and both myself and other party member who got the halibut got horrible horrible food poisoning. It’s disturbing to know that a place in the middle of nowhere that people 9/10 travel ours too, are serving edible and toxic food. I am beside myself that I have a parasite/disease in my body from a place like this. I assume it’s worse than Cracker Barrel. It’s unfortunate you can’t just buy a ticket to the show. Will not be returning and will not be recommending to others.

Kitten K.

Wow absolutely amazing place to enjoy a performance. Food was delicious. The decor of restaurant was enchanting! And of course the Elvis performances were wonderful! Great shopping and of course tastey bakery items .

J- T.

On January 26th, 2025, at 1:15 p.m., the skies over the Fireside Dinner Theatre in Fort Atkinson Wisconsin were illuminated with an effervescent light that can be seen for miles. Why? Because inside the cozy fireside theater, Elvis fans were buzzing with excitement, eagerly waiting with rational exuberance for the start of the tribute show dedicated to the one and only King of Rock and Roll, Elvis Presley.

The Elvis performers, Travis Powell and Taylor Rodriguez, along with their band members and ensemble members blew everyone away with their incredible performance. They rocked the circular stage with such passion that it felt like they owned the place. The thunderous applause, cheers, and laughter echoed through the theater, leaving everyone craving more. And guess what? They got it! They had been given an unforgettable experience!

And speaking of unforgettable, proving again that Elvis only surrounds himself with the best annd the brightest Ensemble member Kieu T. Grisby proved flexibility is key to performing on stage. He transformed his right leg into a makeshift guitar and played air guitar alongside the band and Elvis as they jammed. Amidst all the cheering, he hopped around the stage on one leg, an amazing feat (or would that be foot) that left the audience spellbound. (You have to see it to believe it!)

This concert wasn't just a special event for everyone in the audience. It was also a momentous occasion for a young man who had been a die-hard Elvis fan at the fireside for seven years. Back in 2017, during his first visit as an early teenager, he got a scarf from Elvis, and that left such an impression on him as Elvis is his hero. He had been hoping maybe this would be another lucky year. (Scarves stopped being given out because of COVID) His front-row seat and Elvis-inspired outfit caught the performers' attention, and he was lucky enough to be given a scarf by Elvis and it was captured by the kindness of a staff member!

After the show, we got to meet the entertainers, and they were so nice and took photos with him.

The Fireside theater proved once again why it's such a great place to go for a family night out. They have amazing food and entertainment, and it's always a fun time and great memories for everyone

sabrina O.

The staff is super friendly they treat you like you are a billionaire. The atmosphere makes it feel like you are on an expensive vacation. The food makes you feel like you are visiting a different country with all the excitement and wonder. The actor do such a great job that you would swear you were on Broadway. All of this it's very reasonably priced especially if you do the 4 for 3 Sunday afternoon show. But the buffet is also exceptional. If you've never been, you need to go at least once.

Barb S.

When you purchase your tickets, you choose which meal you would like from their menu for that particular show.... But there are always upgrade options you can get at the table when you get there. I haven't been there in a few years and they've brightened up the atmosphere and it's very comfortable and unique with beautiful glass work, water fountains, fires burning in fire places. The waitress was attentive. The food was very good. Nice quality and good flavors. I had a coconut chicken that was very moist and had a nice sweet glaze on it. West Side Story show was amazing..... How they were able to get that many cast members on that stage is phenomenal. The choreography needed to make that all happen was great. It was a great evening to celebrate our son's 18th birthday.