Felton Pizza - Felton, Delaware

RC3 ?. B. C. C.

So I really want to love this place, I have tried 3 times, different items and same items. The standard bar pie is ok, it’s not bad at all, but it not great. There Sicilian is the go to, the sweeter sauce and dough flavor burst here, one thing is, each time the doughs been slightly soggy or undercooked, or both to be honest. This crust needs to par bake then layer it and finish it out, and I think it would be a staple. The wings are your common pizza shop wings. The staff is absolutely awesome, which is why I returned to try again and again. This shop really should emphasize the Sicilian and own it, make it there staple. The Stromboli, fantastic job on the dough! I mean top notch. The insides a bit undercooked, possible try to caramelize the onions and peppers, and then introduce them inside for the bake, also if you slit a couple air pockets on the top, it will allow it to vent and work the inside. I think this pizza shop has potential to be great! 3 solid stars. If you live close by it will do, would I drive from a town away… no. I think they will kick it up a notch and really hit the nail on the head soon!

A B.

After a delivery I passed the small spot. Turned around and ordered takeout. Fresh dough for my sausage roll that was absolutely delicious. The peppers were fresh and there was sausage in every bite. This can be shared with another person, cause it’s 10-12” long. I’d stop in again for this one. Thanks.

Chris C.

I have not ordered here and won't be ordering from anywhere that charges 65¢ for each topping on a cheese steak. Even lettuce! And then a $1.50 convenience fee for pick up orders! No thanks!

Gary M.

The pizza here never fails. They are always quick to have it ready and they deliver which is great. If you're hungry def stop in here and give them a try sometime.

J

Got a cheesesteak from here yesterday and it was pretty good no complaints. I get mine with onions and provolone. Roll was good enough and steak chopped how I like it. They used red onions which was different but fine with me. Provolone and steak mix was on point.

Guy behind the counter seemed kinda clueless and wasn’t the nicest in the world, but I also could care less about that. As long as I get fed and pay the right price. Whatever.

Overall would definitely stop back in. Decent enough food at decent enough prices.

Christine W.

Yesterday was my birthday. My husband decided to order a pizza, so we called Felton Pizza. The gentleman on the phone was kind. The wait time wasn't long. When our pizza was delivered to our home, we had the kindest woman. She prayed with me and sang happy birthday to me, wich meant the world to me. We're in the process of renovating and moving into a new home, so we've been pretty stressed lately. I don't know this woman's name, but I appreciated that she took the time to do that for me.

... the pizza was pretty good, too

Ashlee O.

First time trying this restaurant. I ordered for delivery. Pizza was delivered hot and was good. Not a fan of the crust. Will be ordering again.

Ashley E.

Edit: I order from here probably once a month or so but the last three or four times have been awful. Pizza has been underdone and toppings haven't been cooked all the way. Disappointing, this will be the last time I order for a good while.

Delicious and inexpensive pizza!